Permanent URL to this publication: http://dx.doi.org/10.5167/uzh-34225
Barden, G; Weber, R (2010). Rhetorics of authority: Leviticus and the Analects compared. Asiatische Studien / Études Asiatiques, 64(1):173-240.
The biblical text Leviticus and the Confucian Analects might appear as neither an obvious nor a very promising choice for a comparative philosophical exercise. To be sure, both texts now and then do share some similarity in matter. But such similarity in matter upon closer examination and contextualisation frequently turns out to be undermined by overt differences which call into question the comparative effort. Our comparison therefore proceeds from a different angle and is motivated by an asserted similarity in rhetoric, by which we mean to claim no more than that both texts record situations in which someone speaks to someone else. Moreover, there is a dominant speaker in each text, the Lord and the Master respectively, whose words seem to carry authority. What kind of authority is concerned in each case it is the aim of this paper to investigate. We do so by first giving an account of what philological and historical research tells us about these texts in order to better understand the task and complexities with which translators were and still are grappling when bringing these texts into the English language. Our main concern then is with a philosophical investigation into the rhetorics of authority as it presents itself to us in standard and influential English translations of Leviticus and the Analects. In the end, we offer some salient comparisons of the two texts as they appear to each author of this article. This will allow the comparison to arise in the eyes of our readers, whose sight quite naturally will be different from ours.
240 downloads since deposited on 26 May 2010
106 downloads since 12 months
|Item Type:||Journal Article, refereed, original work|
|Communities & Collections:||08 University Research Priority Programs > Asia and Europe
Journals > Asiatische Studien / Études Asiatiques > Archive > 64 (2010) > 1
|Dewey Decimal Classification:||950 History of Asia
180 Ancient, medieval & eastern philosophy
|Deposited On:||26 May 2010 18:33|
|Last Modified:||01 Apr 2014 10:18|
|Publisher:||Schweizerische Asiengesellschaft / Verlag Peter Lang|
Users (please log in): suggest update or correction for this item
Repository Staff Only: item control page