Header

UZH-Logo

Maintenance Infos

Is the body secular? Circumcision, religious freedom, and bodily integrity


Amesbury, Richard (2016). Is the body secular? Circumcision, religious freedom, and bodily integrity. DISKUS. The on-disk journal of international religious studies, 18(1):1-10.

Abstract

Recent legal and public debates over circumcision in Germany have tended to pit religious freedom against bodily integrity. This paper examines the background assumptions about religion and the body on which this framing depends. Insofar as the body is assumed to represent a fixed point determinable independently of ‘religion’, to frame the debate over circumcision in terms of a clash between rights pertaining respectively to religion and the body is, I argue, to circumscribe and contain religion within boundaries marked by the non-religious and non-negotiable. The secular body is thus not simply an additional consideration to be weighed against religious freedom but a condition of and limit to the modern conception of (free) religion itself. If the physical body is a synecdoche for the social system, the normative, uncircumcised body can be interpreted as standing in for the universalist order of secular law.

Abstract

Recent legal and public debates over circumcision in Germany have tended to pit religious freedom against bodily integrity. This paper examines the background assumptions about religion and the body on which this framing depends. Insofar as the body is assumed to represent a fixed point determinable independently of ‘religion’, to frame the debate over circumcision in terms of a clash between rights pertaining respectively to religion and the body is, I argue, to circumscribe and contain religion within boundaries marked by the non-religious and non-negotiable. The secular body is thus not simply an additional consideration to be weighed against religious freedom but a condition of and limit to the modern conception of (free) religion itself. If the physical body is a synecdoche for the social system, the normative, uncircumcised body can be interpreted as standing in for the universalist order of secular law.

Statistics

Downloads

1 download since deposited on 21 Feb 2017
1 download since 12 months
Detailed statistics

Additional indexing

Item Type:Journal Article, refereed, original work
Communities & Collections:01 Faculty of Theology > Center for Ethics
Dewey Decimal Classification:170 Ethics
Uncontrolled Keywords:Body, Circumcision, Islam, Judaism, Study of Religion
Language:English
Date:2016
Deposited On:21 Feb 2017 08:47
Last Modified:08 Dec 2017 11:51
Publisher:British Association for the Study of Religions
ISSN:0967-8948
Free access at:Publisher DOI. An embargo period may apply.
Official URL:http://jbasr.com/ojs/index.php/jbasr/article/view/5

Download