Header

UZH-Logo

Maintenance Infos

Validation of post mortem dental CT for disaster victim identification


Ruder, Thomas D; Thali, Yannick A; Rashid, Saiful N A; Mund, Michael T; Thali, Michael J; Hatch, Gary M; Christensen, Angi M; Somaini, Sandra; Ampanozi, Garyfalia (2016). Validation of post mortem dental CT for disaster victim identification. Journal of Forensic Radiology and Imaging, 5:25-30.

Abstract

The objective of this study was to test the accuracy and inter-reader variability of comparative radiologic identification based on dental post mortem computed tomography (PMCT) and ante mortem (AM) dental radiographs.
Five raters with varying degrees of expertize and experience independently compared 115 dental PMCT images to 114 AM dental radiographs to identify matching pairs (n=98), unmatched PMCT images (n=17), and unmatched AM radiographs (n=16). Levels of confidence (LOC) and number of concordant features (NOCF) of matched pairs were documented. Accuracy of matches/exclusions, interrater correlation coefficient and correlation between correct matches/exclusions, LOC and NOCF were calculated for all raters.
Mean accuracy was 92% for matches and 80% for exclusions. Interrater correlation coefficient regarding LOC and NOCF were 0.623 and 0.907 respectively. LOC were correlated with NOCF of matched pairs but accuracy of matches/exclusions was neither correlated to LOC nor to NOCF.
This study shows that visual comparison of PMCT images with AM dental radiographs is a reliable method for identification. Accuracy of identification using PMCT/AM dental radiographs was as high as in comparable studies using post mortem (PM) dental radiographs/AM dental radiographs. Raters with practical experience in forensic identification and experience with the imaging modality (in this case: dental PMCT) achieved higher accuracy than inexperienced raters. Match accuracy did not correlate with subjective confidence or number of concordant features. It is advised to work in teams rather than individually when dealing with real cases in forensic identification, to minimize subjective interpretation and avoid confirmation bias.

Abstract

The objective of this study was to test the accuracy and inter-reader variability of comparative radiologic identification based on dental post mortem computed tomography (PMCT) and ante mortem (AM) dental radiographs.
Five raters with varying degrees of expertize and experience independently compared 115 dental PMCT images to 114 AM dental radiographs to identify matching pairs (n=98), unmatched PMCT images (n=17), and unmatched AM radiographs (n=16). Levels of confidence (LOC) and number of concordant features (NOCF) of matched pairs were documented. Accuracy of matches/exclusions, interrater correlation coefficient and correlation between correct matches/exclusions, LOC and NOCF were calculated for all raters.
Mean accuracy was 92% for matches and 80% for exclusions. Interrater correlation coefficient regarding LOC and NOCF were 0.623 and 0.907 respectively. LOC were correlated with NOCF of matched pairs but accuracy of matches/exclusions was neither correlated to LOC nor to NOCF.
This study shows that visual comparison of PMCT images with AM dental radiographs is a reliable method for identification. Accuracy of identification using PMCT/AM dental radiographs was as high as in comparable studies using post mortem (PM) dental radiographs/AM dental radiographs. Raters with practical experience in forensic identification and experience with the imaging modality (in this case: dental PMCT) achieved higher accuracy than inexperienced raters. Match accuracy did not correlate with subjective confidence or number of concordant features. It is advised to work in teams rather than individually when dealing with real cases in forensic identification, to minimize subjective interpretation and avoid confirmation bias.

Statistics

Citations

5 citations in Web of Science®
7 citations in Scopus®
Google Scholar™

Altmetrics

Downloads

0 downloads since deposited on 03 May 2016
0 downloads since 12 months

Additional indexing

Item Type:Journal Article, refereed, original work
Communities & Collections:04 Faculty of Medicine > Institute of Legal Medicine
Dewey Decimal Classification:340 Law
610 Medicine & health
Uncontrolled Keywords:Forensic radiology; Forensic identification; Dental identification; Post mortem CT; Post mortem dental-CT
Language:English
Date:June 2016
Deposited On:03 May 2016 15:14
Last Modified:04 May 2016 08:12
Publisher:Elsevier
ISSN:2212-4780
Publisher DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jofri.2016.01.006

Download