Header

UZH-Logo

Maintenance Infos

Warum hat Plato die ‚ungeschriebene Lehre‛ nicht geschrieben? - Einige vorläufige Bemerkungen


Ferber, Rafael (1992). Warum hat Plato die ‚ungeschriebene Lehre‛ nicht geschrieben? - Einige vorläufige Bemerkungen. In: Rossetti, Livio. Understanding the 'Phaedrus'. Second edition. Proceedings of the Second Symposium Platonicum. St. Augustin: Academia Verlag, 138-155.

Abstract

The article asks the question, "Why did Plato not write his 'unwritten doctrines'?", and finds the answer in the combination of two obstacles. The first derives from the limitations of the episteme available to an embodied soul about such subjects as the essence of the good. Even if the dialectician has access to a kind of knowledge, the lack of fit between the unchanging essences and the precarious logoi which aim to identify them (and allow others some measure of access to them) could never be fully overcome. At most, Socrates (or Plato] can lead souls only to an incomplete account of them: even to the most expert dialectician, only a claim to knowledge but no unsurpassable certainty may be available. An even greater obstacle lies in the audience or readership itself: no short cut to understanding is possible, and yet a mere written presentation, which is all they have, is just a short cut, and so holds out an empty promise.

Abstract

The article asks the question, "Why did Plato not write his 'unwritten doctrines'?", and finds the answer in the combination of two obstacles. The first derives from the limitations of the episteme available to an embodied soul about such subjects as the essence of the good. Even if the dialectician has access to a kind of knowledge, the lack of fit between the unchanging essences and the precarious logoi which aim to identify them (and allow others some measure of access to them) could never be fully overcome. At most, Socrates (or Plato] can lead souls only to an incomplete account of them: even to the most expert dialectician, only a claim to knowledge but no unsurpassable certainty may be available. An even greater obstacle lies in the audience or readership itself: no short cut to understanding is possible, and yet a mere written presentation, which is all they have, is just a short cut, and so holds out an empty promise.

Statistics

Altmetrics

Downloads

38 downloads since deposited on 26 Aug 2016
28 downloads since 12 months
Detailed statistics

Additional indexing

Item Type:Book Section, refereed, original work
Communities & Collections:06 Faculty of Arts > Institute of Philosophy
Dewey Decimal Classification:100 Philosophy
Language:German
Date:1992
Deposited On:26 Aug 2016 09:18
Last Modified:13 Mar 2017 07:33
Publisher:Academia Verlag
Series Name:International Plato Studies
ISBN:978-3-89665-663-6
Additional Information:Zweite Auflage: 2016
Related URLs:http://www.academia-verlag.de/titel/69663.htm (Publisher)

Download

Download PDF  'Warum hat Plato die ‚ungeschriebene Lehre‛ nicht geschrieben? - Einige vorläufige Bemerkungen'.
Preview
Content: Published Version
Filetype: PDF
Size: 971kB