Header

UZH-Logo

Maintenance Infos

Was und wie hat Sokrates gewusst?


Ferber, Rafael (2007). Was und wie hat Sokrates gewusst? Elenchos, 28(1):5-39.

Abstract

The first part of the paper (p. 10-21) tries to answer the first question of the title and describes a set of seven “knowledge-claims” made by Socrates: 1. There is a distinction between right opinion and knowledge. 2. Virtue is knowledge. 3. Nobody willingly does wrong. 4. To do injustice is the greatest evil for the wrongdoer himself. 5. An even greater evil is if the wrongdoer is not punished. 6. The just person is happy; the unjust person is unhappy. 7. The pleasant is not the good. These claims seem to be the “few” (oliga) (Men. 98 b3) but “very important” (kallista) (Grg. 472 c8) things that Socrates claims to know. The second part (p. 22-39) tries to answer the second question and defends the thesis that the supposed “knowledge” of Socrates is dianoetic, but not noetic. The main new idea of this paper is the comparison of the Socratic knowledge-claims with the upper states of the mind symbolized in the Divided Line, noesis and dianoia (cf. R. 511 d7-e1).

Abstract

The first part of the paper (p. 10-21) tries to answer the first question of the title and describes a set of seven “knowledge-claims” made by Socrates: 1. There is a distinction between right opinion and knowledge. 2. Virtue is knowledge. 3. Nobody willingly does wrong. 4. To do injustice is the greatest evil for the wrongdoer himself. 5. An even greater evil is if the wrongdoer is not punished. 6. The just person is happy; the unjust person is unhappy. 7. The pleasant is not the good. These claims seem to be the “few” (oliga) (Men. 98 b3) but “very important” (kallista) (Grg. 472 c8) things that Socrates claims to know. The second part (p. 22-39) tries to answer the second question and defends the thesis that the supposed “knowledge” of Socrates is dianoetic, but not noetic. The main new idea of this paper is the comparison of the Socratic knowledge-claims with the upper states of the mind symbolized in the Divided Line, noesis and dianoia (cf. R. 511 d7-e1).

Statistics

Downloads

259 downloads since deposited on 22 Aug 2008
60 downloads since 12 months
Detailed statistics

Additional indexing

Item Type:Journal Article, refereed, original work
Communities & Collections:06 Faculty of Arts > Institute of Philosophy
Dewey Decimal Classification:100 Philosophy
Uncontrolled Keywords:Sokrates
Language:German
Date:2007
Deposited On:22 Aug 2008 08:48
Last Modified:06 Dec 2017 14:10
Publisher:Bibliopolis
ISSN:0392-7342
Related URLs:http://www.bibliopolis.it/rivis2.html (Publisher)
http://www.zora.uzh.ch/3353/

Download

Download PDF  'Was und wie hat Sokrates gewusst?'.
Preview
Content: Published Version
Language: German
Filetype: PDF
Size: 517kB
Download PDF  'Was und wie hat Sokrates gewusst?'.
Preview
Content: Published Version
Language: English
Filetype: PDF (Shortened english version)
Size: 71kB
Filetype: Other (Coversheet Pages conversion from application/pdf to application/pdf)