Header

UZH-Logo

Maintenance Infos

Input Control and Random Choice: Improving the Selection Process for Journal Articles


Osterloh, Margit; Frey, Bruno S (2011). Input Control and Random Choice: Improving the Selection Process for Journal Articles. Working paper series / Department of Economics No. 25, University of Zurich.

Abstract

The process by which scholarly papers are selected for publication in a journal is faced with serious problems. The referees rarely agree and often are biased. This paper discusses two alternative measures to evaluate scholars. The first alternative suggests input control. The second one proposes that the referees should decide only whether a paper reaches a minimal level of quality. Within the resulting set, each paper should be chosen randomly. This procedure has advantages but also disadvantages. The more weight that is given to input control and random mechanism, the more likely it is that unconventional and innovative articles are published.

Abstract

The process by which scholarly papers are selected for publication in a journal is faced with serious problems. The referees rarely agree and often are biased. This paper discusses two alternative measures to evaluate scholars. The first alternative suggests input control. The second one proposes that the referees should decide only whether a paper reaches a minimal level of quality. Within the resulting set, each paper should be chosen randomly. This procedure has advantages but also disadvantages. The more weight that is given to input control and random mechanism, the more likely it is that unconventional and innovative articles are published.

Statistics

Downloads

45 downloads since deposited on 25 Nov 2011
9 downloads since 12 months
Detailed statistics

Additional indexing

Item Type:Working Paper
Communities & Collections:03 Faculty of Economics > Department of Economics
Working Paper Series > Department of Economics
Dewey Decimal Classification:330 Economics
JEL Classification:A1, A10, D02, H83, L23, M50
Language:English
Date:September 2011
Deposited On:25 Nov 2011 10:13
Last Modified:07 Dec 2017 09:53
Series Name:Working paper series / Department of Economics
ISSN:1664-7041
Official URL:http://www.econ.uzh.ch/wp.html

Download

Download PDF  'Input Control and Random Choice: Improving the Selection Process for Journal Articles'.
Preview
Filetype: PDF
Size: 203kB