Header

UZH-Logo

Maintenance Infos

The linguistic doctrine revisited


Glock, Hans Johann (2003). The linguistic doctrine revisited. In: Keil, G; Gluer-Pagin, K. Fifty Years of Quine's Two Dogmas. Graz: Rodopi, 143-170.

Abstract

At present, there is an almost universal consensus that the linguistic doctrine of logical necessity is grotesque. This paper explores avenues for rehabilitating a limited version of the doctrine, according to which the special status of analytic statements like 'All vixens are female' is to be explained by reference to language. Far from being grotesque, this appeal to language has a respectable philosophical pedigree and chimes with common sense, as Quine came to realize. The problem lies in developing it in a way that avoids the powerful objections facing previous versions of the linguistic doctrine. I argue tentatively that this can be done by reconciling Wittgenstein's claim that such statements have a normative role with Carnap's concession that they are true.

Abstract

At present, there is an almost universal consensus that the linguistic doctrine of logical necessity is grotesque. This paper explores avenues for rehabilitating a limited version of the doctrine, according to which the special status of analytic statements like 'All vixens are female' is to be explained by reference to language. Far from being grotesque, this appeal to language has a respectable philosophical pedigree and chimes with common sense, as Quine came to realize. The problem lies in developing it in a way that avoids the powerful objections facing previous versions of the linguistic doctrine. I argue tentatively that this can be done by reconciling Wittgenstein's claim that such statements have a normative role with Carnap's concession that they are true.

Statistics

Altmetrics

Additional indexing

Item Type:Book Section, refereed, original work
Communities & Collections:06 Faculty of Arts > Institute of Philosophy
Dewey Decimal Classification:100 Philosophy
Language:English
Date:2003
Deposited On:18 May 2012 08:58
Last Modified:07 Dec 2017 12:19
Publisher:Rodopi
Series Name:Grazer Philosophische Studien
Number:66
ISBN:90-420-0948-9
Related URLs:http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/rodopi/gps/2003/00000066/00000001/art00008

Download

Full text not available from this repository.