Skulls and stories: creating the value of bones in Johann Friedrich Blumenbach’s collection

Abstract

This article focuses on the famous skull collection of the German naturalist Johann Friedrich Blumenbach (1752–1840) to demonstrate that human remains in early modern scientific collections possessed an important but often underestimated economic value in addition to their well-known scientific and social worth. Blumenbach’s skulls are thus presented as a part of a vigorous early modern ‘necro-economy’ and as a product of its networks. The article highlights three strategies of enrichment which were used to create the value of these bones: reference to scientific values, the use of emotions and story-telling. The last two strategies in particular are relevant to present-day debates concerning the restitution of musealized human remains, for their analysis helps us deconstruct a perceptual bias that tends to contrast a Western and predominantly ‘scientific’ (and thus seemingly universal) value of collected human remains with theoretically ‘softer’ cultural values allegedly attributed to them in their countries of origin.