Header

UZH-Logo

Maintenance Infos

Warum hat Platon die "ungeschriebene Lehre" nicht geschrieben?


Ferber, Rafael (2007). Warum hat Platon die "ungeschriebene Lehre" nicht geschrieben? München: C.H. Beck.

Abstract

The debate over Plato’s “ so called unwritten doctrines”, which he communicated only to a small circle of trusted disciples, has caused a stir among philosophers in recent decades. Rafael Ferber assumes a differentiated position in this controversy. He is convinced that the unwritten doctrines did exist, but that Plato, for reasons inherent in the process of gaining knowledge, was unable to communicate these doctrines even to his closest disciples. In this book, Ferber outlines the discussion and summarizes the standpoints of greatest interest.

Since Aristotle, we have known that Plato did not put his most important teachings into writing, but instead communicated them orally to the inner circle of his disciples. Although the extant dialogues pass down Plato’s “exoteric” doctrines, his most important “esoteric” insights were not meant for the general public. The content and significance of these “so called unwritten doctrines” have become the subject of debate in philosophical circles.
Fifteen years ago, at the height of the controversy over these doctrines, Ferber entered the fray with a small book. He proposed that Plato was also unable to communicate the unwritten doctrines because the highest principles (i.e. the subject of the “so called unwritten doctrines”) cannot be known as such due to an epistemological paradox. Ferber’s alternative position met with great respect and acceptance, although in individual cases it was also rejected.
Ferber’s new book again presents the text of 1991, but significantly expands on it through new perspectives and an outline of the discussion it triggered. In this book, the reader learns what is meant by Plato’s “so called unwritten doctrines” and what the controversy is all about.

Abstract

The debate over Plato’s “ so called unwritten doctrines”, which he communicated only to a small circle of trusted disciples, has caused a stir among philosophers in recent decades. Rafael Ferber assumes a differentiated position in this controversy. He is convinced that the unwritten doctrines did exist, but that Plato, for reasons inherent in the process of gaining knowledge, was unable to communicate these doctrines even to his closest disciples. In this book, Ferber outlines the discussion and summarizes the standpoints of greatest interest.

Since Aristotle, we have known that Plato did not put his most important teachings into writing, but instead communicated them orally to the inner circle of his disciples. Although the extant dialogues pass down Plato’s “exoteric” doctrines, his most important “esoteric” insights were not meant for the general public. The content and significance of these “so called unwritten doctrines” have become the subject of debate in philosophical circles.
Fifteen years ago, at the height of the controversy over these doctrines, Ferber entered the fray with a small book. He proposed that Plato was also unable to communicate the unwritten doctrines because the highest principles (i.e. the subject of the “so called unwritten doctrines”) cannot be known as such due to an epistemological paradox. Ferber’s alternative position met with great respect and acceptance, although in individual cases it was also rejected.
Ferber’s new book again presents the text of 1991, but significantly expands on it through new perspectives and an outline of the discussion it triggered. In this book, the reader learns what is meant by Plato’s “so called unwritten doctrines” and what the controversy is all about.

Statistics

Citations

2 citations in Microsoft Academic

Altmetrics

Downloads

24 downloads since deposited on 23 Mar 2009
22 downloads since 12 months
Detailed statistics

Additional indexing

Item Type:Monograph
Communities & Collections:06 Faculty of Arts > Institute of Philosophy
Dewey Decimal Classification:100 Philosophy
Language:German
Date:2007
Deposited On:23 Mar 2009 14:53
Last Modified:01 Aug 2018 06:21
Publisher:C.H. Beck
Number of Pages:176
ISBN:978-3-406-55824-5
OA Status:Green
Related URLs:http://www.beck-shop.de/Ferber-Platon-ungeschriebene-Lehre-geschrieben/productview.aspx?product=19019 (Publisher)

Download

Download PDF  'Warum hat Platon die "ungeschriebene Lehre" nicht geschrieben?'.
Preview
Filetype: Image (JPEG) (Titelbild)
Size: 94kB
Download PDF  'Warum hat Platon die "ungeschriebene Lehre" nicht geschrieben?'.
Preview
Content: Other
Filetype: PDF (Inhaltsverzeichnis)
Size: 35kB