Publication:

Pragmatic norms are all you need – why the symbol grounding problem does not apply to LLMs

Date

Date

Date
2024
Conference or Workshop Item
Published version

Citations

Citation copied

Gubelmann, R. (2024). Pragmatic norms are all you need – why the symbol grounding problem does not apply to LLMs. 11663–11678. https://doi.org/10.18653/v1/2024.emnlp-main.651

Abstract

Abstract

Abstract

Do LLMs fall prey to Harnad’s symbol grounding problem (SGP), as it has recently been claimed? We argue that this is not the case. Starting out with countering the arguments of Bender and Koller (2020), we trace the origins of the SGP to the computational theory of mind (CTM), and we show that it only arises with natural language when questionable theories of meaning are presupposed. We conclude by showing that it would apply to LLMs only if they were interpreted in the manner of how the CTM conceives the mind, i.e., by postulating th

Metrics

Downloads

7 since deposited on 2025-03-06
Acq. date: 2025-11-12

Views

4 since deposited on 2025-03-06
2last week
Acq. date: 2025-11-12

Citations

Additional indexing

Creators (Authors)

  • Gubelmann, Reto
    affiliation.icon.alt

Event Title

Event Title

Event Title
Proceedings of the 2024 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing

Event Location

Event Location

Event Location
Miami

Event Country

Event Country

Event Country
Florida, USA

Event Start Date

Event Start Date

Event Start Date
2024-11-01

Event End Date

Event End Date

Event End Date
2024-11-01

Page range/Item number

Page range/Item number

Page range/Item number
11663

Page end

Page end

Page end
11678

Item Type

Item Type

Item Type
Conference or Workshop Item

Dewey Decimal Classifikation

Dewey Decimal Classifikation

Dewey Decimal Classifikation

Keywords

NLP, Linguistik, Symbol Grounding, Philosophie

Language

Language

Language
English

Date available

Date available

Date available
2025-03-06

OA Status

OA Status

OA Status
Green

Free Access at

Free Access at

Free Access at
Unspecified

Metrics

Downloads

7 since deposited on 2025-03-06
Acq. date: 2025-11-12

Views

4 since deposited on 2025-03-06
2last week
Acq. date: 2025-11-12

Citations

Citations

Citation copied

Gubelmann, R. (2024). Pragmatic norms are all you need – why the symbol grounding problem does not apply to LLMs. 11663–11678. https://doi.org/10.18653/v1/2024.emnlp-main.651

Green Open Access
Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Files

Files

Files
Files available to download:1

Files

Files

Files
Files available to download:1
Loading...
Thumbnail Image